MUSICIAN
APRIL 1996
IDAHO
Three Sheets to the Wind
(Caroline)
From the way Idaho’s front
man Jeff Martin sings, you’d think he’d just had a good cry before stepping to
the microphone. His foggy baritone quivers, breaks, and strains for high notes
as he slurs his somber lyrics. “I watch the
sun go out” is the first line of “Shame,”
joining other choice phrases like “Thirty years are gone” and “Late
December is what I’m feeling.” Even when
the band cranks the amps and blasts off, as on “Catapult” or “Pomegranate
Bleeding,” they sound deeply unhappy.
Why doesn’t all this weepiness get annoying? Partly due to Martin’s
sincerity, but mainly because of his musical
savvy. Writing on a
four-string guitar in a variety of odd
tunings, he conjures dancing melodies that always feature at least one clever
twist. He’s also got a brilliant chordal sense, favoring close intervals like major and minor seconds and
juxtaposing chords in surprising ways. Take the beginning of “Get You Back”—Db-maj7&5-Absus2-Bbmaj9; not the most common
chords, certainly not a standard
progression. Or check out the album’s centerpiece, “No One’s Watching,” as
Martin and guitarist Dan Seta
refrain from playing full chords for nearly the whole song, choosing instead to
establish an F# drone. Meanwhile, Terrence Borden’s bass traces around
the key signature, starting on the fifth, resting tantalizingly on the third, taking four full measures before
finally joining the guitarists. It’s a short meeting, though, and Borden’s soon
off again on his own harmonic path.
Fine as Idaho’s previous two albums were, Three Sheets
to the Wind sounds warmer, more expansive. Maybe it’s because there’s a real group
involved (in the past, Martin pretty
much was the band). Whatever the reason, songs like “Stare at the Sky”
and “A Sound Awake” boast a grandeur only hinted at before. Music doesn’t come
much sadder than this, or much prettier.
—Mac Randall